Protein Review
So you’re looking to get a nice big tub of protein.
Which kind should you get? Whey? Soy? Casein?
Is one brand better than another? How can you know which brand to get?
When should you take it? Before workout? After workout? Morning? Evening?
How much should you take? 1 serving per day? 2? 3?
So many protein questions are out there, and how do we get an effective plan of attack to make the most of our protein supplementation?
Here’s my abbreviated review of who, what, when, where, and how about protein!
I’ve tried several types and several brands. The first thing to determine when selecting a type or brand of protein is “What do I need this for?”. Usually, it’s because you need protein supplementation to hit your target percentages for protein (50% on fat shredder, 40% on balanced, 30% on endurance maximizer). If you can eat enough protein in your diet without protein powder, then you may not need to buy any protein supplements! But this is rare, as most of us don’t get enough from lean meats, etc. on a daily basis.
So, from tracking your diet, you’ll determine how much protein you need in your diet from protein powder per day to hit your percentages. For me, this is typically about 80-100g (in addition to what I get from my diet). Run your own numbers to determine that. It’s very difficult for me to answer someone who asks “How many protein shakes should I take per day?” because like I said above, it depends! You may need none. You may need 4. Run the numbers and be sure you hit your target numbers and percentages for the phase of the nutrition plan you are on.
Next, assuming you’ve decided you need protein powder in your daily routine, which one should you get? Some are cheap, some are expensive, and there are lots in between. I’ve tried cheap (like EAS whey from Sam’s Club), and I’ve tried above average cost (Wheybolic Extreme 60), and I’ve tried several in between (Muscle Infusion, O.N. Gold Standard, etc.). I haven’t tried some of the high end ones because I’m happy enough with what I’ve used so far. The key thing to look at is the nutritional profile. You want maximum protein, minimal fat, and minimal carbs. I’m currently using Dymatize Iso-100 because it is reasonably priced and has a great % of protein per serving (24g of protein in a 106 calorie serving).
And just because one type of protein may have more grams of protein in a serving doesn’t mean it’s better. You have to look at the size of the serving and the total calories of the serving. Do the math and figure out which protein has the best ratio of protein calories to total calories. For instance, Wheybolic Extreme 60 has 20g of protein in a 93 calorie scoop (80 of the 93 calories are protein = 86% protein). This is better than ON Gold, which has 24g of protein in a 130 calorie serving (96 of the 130 calories are protein = 74% protein).
It’s also nice to have the essential amino acids in high quantities (some have more than others). I’ve found that a good “value” is O.N. Gold Standard — it’s not the cheapest, but it’s not the most expensive either, and it’s got solid nutritional information. I used it a lot for the first several months.
Another consideration you have to make is whether or not you want to go with whey as your protein powder. Casein protein is great in the evenings because it is slower to digest and stays in your system longer. This is perfect for overnight use by your muscles. I tried some, but got a horrible tasting version and had to toss it out! I never resumed my search, and I just use whey in the evening LOL! If you’ve found a casein protein that you like to use in the evening, perfect!
I haven’t used soy protein powder myself (there are various debates about estrogen levels in men from too much soy protein, so I figured why risk it). Soy is a good protein though. My wife has used it and likes it. You might want to consider soy protein if you are allergic to whey (although even those with lactose allergies often do fine with whey because it is isolated from the milk and all lactose is “supposedly” removed). But if you have milk allergies, check first before buying a whole tub!
There are also vegan plant based protein powders available. I’ve used the Sun Warrior “Warrior Blend”. It’s a great protein (a bit grainy texture, as all plant based proteins are, but high quality).
And finally, once you’ve figured out how much protein you need, which type and brand you are going to use, and you’ve added it to your diet, the final question is when should you use it to best fit around your workout times?
It’s good to have protein in your system before working out. This may require you to use one of your shakes before a workout (45min to 1 hour before). But if you already have regular food on board from a meal, then you won’t need it then. It’s also good to get protein in your system within an hour after your workout. Again, this is a great time for a shake, and I’d recommend using it then for sure (I prefer a shake to food just because the balance of amino acids will be better in your protein powder than in a piece of meat, for instance). Post workout is probably the most critical time to consume protein powder because your body is in an anabolic state and ready to repair and grow muscle. And then you’ll also want to be sure you have protein in your system in the evening so your muscles have the fuel they need to recover and grow overnight. This is also very important. I like to take a scoop of whey protein mixed in water between dinner and bedtime.
Other than those obvious times, it is also important that at every meal/snack you fuel your body with protein, so you may find that you like to use protein powder for a morning snack, or an afternoon snack, depending on what else you use for snacks. What you don’t want is a carb-only snack with no protein. Every one of the 5-6 times you eat during the day should have a nice protein source.
I hope this review didn’t confuse you more!! Ask if you have questions about your protein powder or how you are using it and I’ll do my best to answer!
Related Posts:
165 Responses to “Protein Review”
Leave a Reply
NEW – my X2 Results Video!
Wayne’s P90X Results Video
Most Popular Products
The yogurt is okay but not as ideal due to the carbs in it.
haha it was LOL…. I think I will still end up using the greek yogurt. Other than the carbs, is it enough casein according to your opinion?
Probably Brian. But I don’t know. I’m not looking at the label or serving size LOL! YOU ARE!! Tell me the breakdown and I’ll tell you if it’s enough.
Hahaha sorry for being vague. In the 6 oz of plain Greek yogurt, there are 18 grams of protein, 7 carbs, and 0 grams of fat
Well, 18g of protein and 7g of carbs is okay, but obviously not as good as 25g of protein and 1g of carbs (which is what you’d get in a scoop of whey).
okey coach I read the articles and i’ll take creatine every day an i’ll switch to kre alkalyn but i will take only 2 capsules because i’m smaller an if my target is 40% or 50% how many grams of protein are? thanks
Super Max! Next you need to read my article “the nutrition guide” to understand how to convert % into grams = http://teamripped.com/p90x-nutrition-guide
Would you suggest one scoop of whey or two scoops before a workout.
iF it’s a day workout, do you have to take anything before the workout.
Hey Dirk, there is no set rule for scoops of whey before a workout. The key is to get enough protein during your day, spread out between your meals and snacks.
thanks coach,
how about shakeology, is that used along with WHEY? or do you recommend just using one if not the other after a workout.
before an early workout I do not have anything other than water, after workout I’ve had a protein bar instead, and 3 egg whites for breakfast. however I plan on changing that and use a shake or whey however I’m unable to decide
Hey Dirk, you can do it either way. I always mix my Shakeology with whey and some natural peanut butter or PB2.
Hey coach, quick question about protein powder. I’m currently using syntha-6 and have been on it for about a month. I take one scoop after morning workout and one before bed. It’s 22gs of protein per scoop but 200 cals, 2 gs of sugar and 13 gs of carbs. Some are saying that it will affect the cutting/lean muscle look that I have and am continuing to work towards. What is your take on it??
Well not right before bed, I take it about 2 hours before going to bed.
Hey Caleb, go ahead and use it for now since you already bought it, but when it’s time for more protein powder, get one with low or no carbs and a high % of protein per serving. You’ll be far better off.
Ok thanks. Hopefully it won’t prevent me from losing body fat and getting continued leanuscle mass.. If so I will stop now and switch to 100% whey I guess.. I’m wanting to gain a little mass while staying lean and below 10% body fat.